Sticky Fingers Delectables - 10 Horseshoe Lake Road - Kauneonga Lake NY 12749
Sticky Fingers Delectables open Daily Through Labor Day 2025
Our Current Hours of Operation Can Be Found Below
voted Best restaurant in kauneonga lake NY for 2022
About Us
Open Letter from the Owner to Our Esteemed Customers
July 4th, 2023
Dear Friends of Sticky Fingers Delectables!
So of late I have been thinking about my business: what makes it tick, and what makes Sticky Fingers Delectables thrive. After almost five years owning this business I thought it now appropriate to share with you some of my thoughts about the ice cream business, and what ice cream achieves in the world.
But wait a minute. Does ice cream 'achieve' anything in the world? I think it does.
When, going on five years ago, I took over Sticky Fingers, I was closing out one chapter of my life (working for a big corporation in a skyscraper in central Manhattan) and beginning another, more bucolic one. Though my 25 years in New York City were exciting and educational, they were also driven by the relentless struggle to compete, achieve, survive and dominate. During those long years I finally came to realize through hard failure that the only thing really worth pursuing in life, in any human life, is happiness, simple gentle happiness, happiness that hurts no one but only hands itself on.
Leaving the glittering skyscrapers of Manhattan behind, this became and still is our One Big Project at Sticky Fingers Delectables: to be a 'happiness factory' for everyone who visits us. It is ONE BIG PROJECT. But, as all of us face so many unexpected and often demoralizing challenges alone and together, I am convinced that over in our cozy little corner shop, tucked away on the lazy shores of Kauneonga Lake, you and I, customers and vendor alike, are doing our very best--together, for a moment, one scoop, one swirl, one billow at a time--to wash away all the tears of the world. THAT'S an achievement, oh yes it is!
Come to us soon and Enter the Empire of Ice Cream and our Happiness Factory.
We thank you for your support of our One Big Project and hope to see you again soon.
~ James
About Our Ice Creams and Sorbets
The ice creams and sorbets we sell at Sticky Fingers are made by Jane’s Ice Cream of Kingston, NY. These fine creams use only the best hormone-free milk from New York State cows and only the finest natural and local ingredients to flavor their ice creams. With no artificial flavors or colors and only plant-based stabilizers, you can rest assured that our tasty confections live up to your quality and taste bud standards. All flavors, except those containing the words "cookie," "cake," "pretzel," or "dough," are gluten free. All of the sorbets are completely dairy-free and made with simple de-seeded and de-fibred whole fruit. All flavors are egg free. All nut flavors are produced at the end of the day, after which all machinery is broken down and sanitized for the next day. If someone in your party has a nut allergy, please inform the server/manager and that member of your party will be served first.
Site Content
Sticky Fingers Delectables Glorious Ice Cream Menu
Hello Kind and Gentle People living in the Empire of Ice Cream!
Many of you have asked us to post a menu before you head over Horseshoe Lake Road-way to Sticky Fingers Delectables.
We are happy to oblige. Swing on by and enjoy our delectable ice creams on the shores of sparkling Kauneonga or under the broad timbered awning of our 200 year old Pavilion..
Here's a listing of the flavors we generally keep stocked at all times. Please note that our vegan flavors often change from week to week; call or text us ahead of your visit and we'll give you the latest on what's available.
All the best and here's to a wondrous and sumptuous summer of laughter and reawakenings!
Apricot Orange Blossom
Banana Cookie^
Coconut* Almond Joy
Cappuccino Kahlua Calypso
Cinnamon Crumb Cake^
Cookie Dough^
Cookies & Cream^
Dulce de Luce
Killer Chocolate
Lavender
Mango (sorbet)
Mint Chip
Peanut* Butter Fudge
Pistacchio Nut*
Raspberry (sorbet)
Salted Caramel Pretzel^
Strawberry
Vanilla
* Contains nuts
^ Contains gluten.
Please inform your server or the manager of any allergies.
Gluten-free cones, home-made whipped cream, sprinkles (rainbow, chocolate, Sticky Fingers Blue), home-made French hot fudge, crushed walnuts are also generally available.
Please note that during off-season (November through April), our ice cream selection may vary due to reduced demand.
Thank you and see you soon!
~ James and the Sticky Fingers Gang